The breakthrough came from a combination of witness accounts and circumstantial evidence revisited by Kelly Siegler and investigator Steve Spingola :
The team discovered that Chisholm’s nephew, Dwayne Taylor , had been using a loaner truck from a local garage that matched the description and sound. cold justice mauldin sc
On , Dwayne Taylor was officially charged with murder and first-degree arson . At the time of the charges, he was already in custody at the Greenville County Detention Center on unrelated domestic violence and assault charges. Aftermath & Legal Action The breakthrough came from a combination of witness
Debra Chisholm, 44, a well-loved single mother and city permit clerk known for her joyful personality. Aftermath & Legal Action Debra Chisholm, 44, a
The truck had a dent that aligned with a scrape on a tree at the crime scene and was missing a cap from a gas can in the bed, linking it to the accelerant used in the arson.
The case went cold for 14 years until Mauldin’s Interim Police Chief George Miller invited the Cold Justice team to review the files. Key Evidence & Arrest