Fullmetal Alchemist (2017) Part 1 〈Windows〉

Trying to fit 27 volumes of manga into 135 minutes resulted in a rushed middle act.

The "Circle-less" transmutation effects are flashy and satisfying to watch.

For newcomers, it is a decent, visually stunning introduction to the world. For die-hard fans, it is a nostalgic—if slightly hollow—tribute to the Elric brothers' bond. Fullmetal Alchemist (2017) PART 1

While visually impressive, the film faced significant hurdles common in the genre:

Filmed in Italy, the movie captures the "Amestris" European aesthetic perfectly, providing a sense of scale often missing in anime adaptations. ⚖️ Critical Reception: The "Live-Action Curse" Trying to fit 27 volumes of manga into

The movie focuses heavily on the Liore incident and the tragic Tucker/Nina arc. 🎨 Visuals and Production

While Ryosuke Yamada gives a spirited performance as Ed, secondary characters like Mustang and Hawkeye feel somewhat sidelined compared to their iconic manga counterparts. 🛡️ Legacy and Sequels For die-hard fans, it is a nostalgic—if slightly

The film follows the core narrative of the Elric brothers: two prodigies who attempt "Human Transmutation" to bring back their deceased mother. The cost is high—Edward loses a leg and an arm, while Alphonse loses his entire body, his soul bound to a suit of armor. Key Story Beats