Reviews for the episode were generally positive, though some critics noted a heavy reliance on "cringe comedy" that occasionally felt unnecessary.
: The episode holds a solid user rating of 8.7/10 on IMDb. Viewer Perspectives [S5E6] Trick-or-Treat
: The pairing of Glenn and Garrett provided some of the episode's biggest laughs. Critics from Telltale TV highlighted that Colton Dunn and Mark McKinney "really churn out the laughs" during these segments. Reviews for the episode were generally positive, though
: Notable costumes include Elias as Edward Scissorhands and Marcus’s elaborate dragon outfit, which he wears despite the store canceling the costume contest. Critics from Telltale TV highlighted that Colton Dunn
In this episode, Amy tries to impress the new District Manager, Maya, by ramping up the store's Halloween spirit. However, things get awkward when Kelly (Jonah’s ex) arrives to deliver signed union cards, leading to a series of uncomfortable distractions. Meanwhile, Garrett uses the store’s "haunted house" to relentlessly prank a terrified Glenn, and Cheyenne and Mateo spend their shift speculating that one of their coworkers might be a serial killer. Critical Reception
“Great Halloween episode! ... Without saying any major spoilers, this isn't the BEST Halloween episode they've done, but it is one of the best episodes this season!” IMDb