The Jalopy JournalIn a dramatic turn, Derek chooses Karen Cartwright (Katharine McPhee) to go on as Marilyn, leaving Ivy Lynn (Megan Hilty) devastated and contemplating a dark path.
Personal takes on the finale often highlight the emotional weight of the rivalry and the quality of the music.
While the show succeeds on stage, the personal lives of the creators remain messy. Julia’s marriage is in shambles, and Eileen finally sees her hard work as a producer pay off, despite the shadow of her ex-husband Jerry. Critical Reception
Episode 15 is a satisfying conclusion to the "Marilyn" arc. It leans into what Smash does best—music, ambition, and the "ghost" of Marilyn Monroe—while setting up the professional and personal stakes for the second season.
